TurboTax 2010 for desktop > online
I noticed this on TurboTax 2010’s web site:
[BEGIN QUOTE]
Completing your return
* Online – Step-by-step Interview questions make tax preparation simple.
* Desktop – Step-by-step Interview questions and the ability to view and complete tax forms just as they appear on paper.
http://turbotax.intuit.com/support/iq/TurboTax/Buyer-s-Guide—Should-I-use-TurboTax-Online-or-Desktop-/GEN12410.html
[END QUOTE]
In other words, the desktop version is more full-featured and lets you interact more with the actual tax forms. I think this would make it a lot easier to understand what’s going on, such as to google IRS info (or read info at irs.gov). Or, to do comparisons if you have different options (such as standard deduction vs. itemized, or married filing jointly vs. filing separate).
If the desktop version has more functionality, then this is really not surprising, because with the online version, they let you answer their tax questions before you pay. So if they showed you the 1040 etc docs that it creates before you paid, then it would be very convenient to use the software without paying for it.
Also, as a general rule, web apps are inherently limited compared to native apps. Web apps run on a generic platform that works inside a web browser. Native apps are integrated into the OS and the OS GUI. This is basically the same argument that Apple uses for not allowing Adobe Flash on iOS – because they want to encourage the development of more native apps. Even if an app uses the cloud, a native app typically has more potential for power, higher performance, OS integration (including OS GUI integration).
Of course the downside is that you don’t get automatic cloud storage and convenient access from anywhere. This is why many cloud services offer both. For example, access to email (or cloud services, such as EverNote) via web pages, desktop apps, and mobile apps. Maybe TurboTax 2010 should offer this. Then, again, it’s just a *.tax2010 file that you could backup however you want.
The other thing about TurboTax 2010 desktop is that it’s priced differently. For the online version they sell you the efile. For the desktop version, they sell you the software (with up to 5 free files). If you’re only doing one efile, then it costs more:
TurboTax 2010 desktop editions pricing: 1040EZ is free. Deluxe says "own a home, made donations or have medical expenses" and costs $60. Premier says "own stocks, bonds, mutual funds or rental properties" and costs $90. officemax.com currently sells them in a box on CD for $10 off.
I just installed TurboTax 2010 on a Windows 7 (AMD64 / x64) computer, and here’s my first impressions. The first thing that killed me is that you can’t press Alt+F to go to the file menu (or Alt+E for Edit, etc). This is a very basic violation of Windows HIG (btw, it’s called mnemonics). This is a very minor thing, but I’m kind a nut about standardized shortcuts and good HIG-based OS GUI integration, so a detail like this does really bothers me. It would be such a tiny GUI code fix. I had a similar reaction when I first tried p4v.exe (Perfoce’s GUI) on Win7, and noticed that it didn’t use the taskbar jump lists (instead, I wrote cmd.exe batch files, and put those on a jump list, which is kludge).
On the other hand, I was at least glad to see the box that toggles between Step-by-Step and Forms view. Unfortunately, it takes a few seconds to switch between them, which really doesn’t make sense, but I guess that’s not a big deal. And I guess a performance bug in the GUI is not a big deal as long as all the actual functionality (ie, does taxes) is good.
Other than those comments, my overall initial impression is very positive. But keep in mind, I’m writing this post before I’ve actually started using it.
I’ll close with a brief (and btw, uneducated) initial impression of H&R Block vs. TurboTax. Intuit is a financial and tax software company (products include TurboTax, Quicken / Mint.com, QuickBooks, Billing Manager, Intuit Eclipse), so you might expect their software to be good. H&R Block is a tax preparation company, so you might expect them to know about taxes. Of course there are some others, such as TaxACT, which sounds similar but costs less.
Update 2011/02/12: A link from Bank of America also gives you a 35% discount, such as TurboTax 2010 Deluxe desktop edition discounted from $59.95 to $44.96.
Pem (Admin) :: 2011/02/11 (Friday, February 11, 2011) :: Financial :: No Comments »
Del.icio.us
Digg
Technorati
Blinklist
Furl
reddit